g1a.jpg (5739 bytes)

A Treatise on the Use
and Effectiveness
of
Hand Grenades
(Simultaneously published in Paris
under the title "La Taille est Importante")

Hand grenade use during the Lake George Tactical has reestablished itself during the last four years.  The recent campaign of 2004 saw the introduction of a British-made grenade, making a scientific study between it and the existing French ordinance possible.

To calm any misconceptions concerning the context of this study, the grenades being examined are a non-lethal variety used in 18th century living history demonstrations.  A general guideline had been suggested to both French and British arsenals that defines grenades as such:



i
ii
iii
iv
v

vi
V. Grenades

Grenades must be made from non-fragmenting rubber tennis balls.
Explosive grenades shall contain less than 500 grains of powder.
Infantry must give ground if confronted by grenades.
One cannot claim a kill with grenades.
No grenades are to be thrown at night, but they can be purposely set off to signal an attack or create a distraction.
No grenades are to be thrown at boats or canoes at any time.


French Grenades

frgrenade2.jpg (7769 bytes)The grenades currently in use by both France and Colonial America consist of a tennis ball, paint, powder, fuse and glue (see Fig. 1.)  They are assembled by first punching a hole into each ball.   Working in half dozen batches, the balls are mounted onto nails set in a board.   A propane torch is then used to burn the fuzz off the tennis balls, and further use of the torch helps to reduce the elasticity of the rubber.  The balls are painted black once cool, and when dry are filled with 480 grains of FFFF black powder using a brass funnel.  A 7" piece of waterproof cannon fuse is glued into the hole and the grenade is complete. 

The French grenade has seen great success in its use on Lake George and elsewhere.  With a diameter of 2.5 inches and weighing  5.5 ounces, the grenade's particular size makes it suitable for mortar use.  The waterproof fuse and powder seal provides a high probability of detonation in water, while the heat-treated rubber shell quickly sheds kinetic energy and increases stability and control to the target.  The all-rubber construction guarantees a non-fragmented explosion that produces smoke and concussion with no discernable flame.

 

British Grenades

britgrenade3.jpg (10940 bytes)October of 2004 saw the introduction of the first British grenade to be used on Lake George in recent history.  It is constructed using a racquet ball filled with 150 grains of powder.  A red waterproof fuse is inserted and secured in place using black utility tape (see Fig. 2.)

These grenades were first used by the British against the French at Black Mountain Point.  Smaller than its French counterpart, the British grenade's diameter measures 2.2 inches and weighs 3.25 ounces.  The racquet ball provides for a highly elastic rubber shell, and although the design complies fully with non-fragmentation standards, it's been reported that these grenades have such a high factor of elasticity that when thrown can bounce off targets and return to detonate at their point of origin.

The second generation British grenade is essentially the same ordinance as the first generation British grenade described above, but with the addition of black paint, the British broad arrow marking and the use of glue instead of utility tape to secure the fuse (see Fig. 3.)  The oil-based black lacquer did not apply well to the racket balls and they have a tendency to stick to things if left for any length of time, even after weeks of drying in low-humidity conditions.  Further tests using a latex-based black paint are in the works.

 

Technical Comparison:

FRENCH GRENADE BRITISH GRENADE
SHELL Tennis Ball Racquet Ball
DIAMETER 2.5 inches 2.2 inches
WEIGHT 5.5 ounces 3.25 ounces
CHARGE 480 grains 150 grains
FUSE 7 inch waterproof 3 inch waterproof
frcutaway1.jpg (8658 bytes) britcutaway1.jpg (6361 bytes)

 

home.jpg (6774 bytes)